Biden Plan ‘Unworkable’ for Florida’s Boat Refugees, Archbishop Says
Reading Time: 4 minutes

Administration plan would accept 30,000 people a month from Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua and Venezuela if they use “legal pathways” to enter.

By Tom Tracy, OSV News

MIAMI (OSV News) — President Joe Biden’s plan to address the influx of asylum-seekers attempting to enter the United States, including boat refugees landing on Florida shores, is likely more a bandage than a permanent solution, according to church officials in southern Florida. However, the plan does open up the possibility of Catholic parishes having a role in sponsoring some asylum-seekers.

Hundreds of migrants from Cuba and Haiti began arriving by boat in greater numbers in late December and the first weeks of 2023. On Jan. 1, approximately 300 people arrived by boat as refugees at Dry Tortugas National Park, located about 70 miles west of Key West, with an additional 45 entering Key West.

National attention to the crisis prompted Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis to sign an executive order activating the Florida National Guard and other state law enforcement agencies to provide increased support to local officials in the Florida Keys.

DeSantis’ office reported that since August 2022, federal, state and local law enforcement have encountered more than 8,000 migrants in waters off the coast of Florida. In addition, in the 2021-2022 fiscal year, 220,000 Cubans were reportedly stopped at the U.S.-Mexican border, almost six times as many as the previous year. President Biden said earlier in January that people from Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua and Venezuela “accounted for most of the people traveling into Mexico to start a new life by getting to the American border and trying to cross.”

In response, the administration recently announced it would begin immediately turning away Cubans as well as Haitians and Nicaraguans who cross the U.S.-Mexico border without authorization. This follows a plan announced last October to limit Venezuelan migrants entering without authorization last year.

For the next two years, the Biden administration plans to accept 30,000 people per month from Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua and Venezuela, offering them work permits if they use “legal pathways” to enter, such as applying in their home countries; have eligible sponsors; and pass vetting and background checks. Those who cross the U.S. border from Mexico will jeopardize their asylum claims.

“The plan doesn’t seem to be workable because it says (refugees) can come in for two years — then what happens after those two years? Will we have renewals like we do for people on Temporary Protected Status, like Salvadorans who have been on TPS for 20 years but with no real path to citizenship?” asked Miami Archbishop Thomas G. Wenski, who spoke with OSV News by telephone Jan. 13.

“It requires somebody to have a sponsor here, so they won’t become a public charge but with only a two-year window for work permits. You wonder what kind of burden that places on family members and it doesn’t address the problem of people coming by boats,” the archbishop said.

A real long-term U.S. policy toward Haiti, Cuba, Venezuela and Nicaragua would have to address the so-called “push-pull” factors driving migrations from those countries to the U.S., Archbishop Wenski noted.

The situation in Haiti has been devolving into one of widespread violence and hopeless poverty, while poor U.S.-Cuba relations have exacerbated economic dysfunction in Cuba, he noted.

Meanwhile, the U.S. faces a shortage of service-industry employees following the global pandemic, but most of those who have arrived in the U.S. in the past year are unable to legally work, pay taxes or contribute to the economic health of the U.S., the archbishop said.

Randy McGrorty, executive director of Catholic Legal Services of the Archdiocese of Miami, cautioned that the numbers of refugees arriving by boat recently are not nearly as large as those seen in the 1980s and 1990s. He said the U.S. southern land borders remain the first point of entry for Cubans and others.

McGrorty also noted that half to two-thirds of the monthly 30,000 asylum-seekers the Biden administration said it will accept are likely to gravitate to south Florida, where they will pursue their asylum claims in U.S. courts and where Cuban, Haitian and Central American populations are already established.

McGrorty said it remains unclear if the new Biden parole program will effectively work to reduce illegal migration pressures at the U.S. border and at sea, but that the plan introduces a new form of U.S. sponsorship for those seeking asylum.

“One thing that is a very interesting concept: It isn’t necessarily a relative or individual who is a sponsor; a parish or a business could sponsor a refugee,” McGrorty said.

“Sponsorship usually had to be through a family member or government agency, so now a parish can sponsor a refugee and I would encourage parishes and businesses to sponsor people — particularly unskilled workers. Individual households can also serve as a sponsor if properly vetted,” he added.

Peter Routsis-Arroyo, CEO of Catholic Charities of the Archdiocese of Miami, noted that while the influx of boat refugees this month has created a minor media storm, the situation has not yet affected church agencies in the region.

But if projections hold true and the Biden parole program introduces additional tens of thousands of asylum seekers to the greater Miami area, that will have ramifications on the local housing situation.

“Miami is a tremendously resilient city. You hear about these buses with migrants going to New York, Chicago and Boston, and they are seeing over the course of the last year upwards of 30,000 or so, whereas Miami has taken in 200,000 in that same period of the last year or year and a half,” Routsis-Arroyo said.

Catholic Charities will invariably play a role in assisting those who “fall between the cracks” of sponsorship and employment, he said, in some cases helping them relocate internally to regions where they have family or a willing sponsor.

Tom Tracy is an OSV News correspondent writing from Florida.

Featured image: Haitian migrants line up as they wait for a QR code to register their migratory situation in Tapachula, Mexico, Dec. 29, 2021. The Diocese of Nuevo Laredo has issued and urgent appeal for assistance as hundreds of Haitian migrants arrive in the oft-violent city hoping to apply for asylum in the United States when Title 42 ends in May. (CNS photo/Jose Torres, Reuters)

Magazine Past Issues

About the author

OSV News

OSV News is a national and international wire service reporting on Catholic issues and issues that affect Catholics. It is a part of OSV Publishing, a division of OSV, the largest English-language Catholic publishing company in the United States. OSV, based in Huntington, Indiana, was founded in 1912.